The NFL trade deadline is the only time during the football season when Tuesday gets just as much attention as the rest of the week. Either teams are moving backwards to set up for the future, or moving forward to win now. And this year, there was no shortage of big moves for those contenders.
The team that gained the most player-wise was the Jacksonville Jaguars, who got significant help defensively with the additions of Davon Godchaux, Jessie Bates and Jordan Davis. Godchaux and Davis give them much-needed help on the defensive, as injuries have caused that position to run thin for them.
Bates and Davis have proven they can be leaders of championship-caliber teams, with Bates helping the Cincinnati Bengals reach the Super Bowl in 2021, and Davis winning the Super Bowl in 2024 with the Eagles. With a 6-2 record and the top seed in the AFC South, the Jaguars are in an excellent spot to contend this year. Last year, they won the division before losing a close game to the Buffalo Bills in the Wild Card Round.
The Indianapolis Colts, also in the AFC South, are moving in the opposite direction. They traded away a few of their high-end players, including Josh Downs and Keenan Allen. Additionally, they traded away two All-Pro talents, Deforest Buckner and Quinten Nelson.
Allen and Buckner were both traded to the San Francisco 49ers, giving them veteran presence and much-needed depth across multiple positions that have been affected by injuries this season.
Nelson was traded to the Seattle Seahawks, the reigning Super Bowl champions. They have started the season much slower than most expected, so they’re hoping Nelson can help bring them back to the big game.
Downs went to the Kansas City Chiefs, giving them a true receiving threat that can stretch the field. Currently, their leading receiver is averaging under 50 receiving yards per game, and Downs will give them a much more consistent threat out wide.
Another AFC South team in rebuild mode is the Tennessee Titans, who parted ways with All-Pro mainstay Jeffery Simmons, along with Amani Hooker. Sitting at just 1-7 and having the fourth pick last year, it almost felt as if these moves were inevitable.
Hooker went to the Buffalo Bills to give them help in the secondary. Ever since Micah Hyde and Jordan Poyer both left, it has been a large shuffle of players playing the safety spots in Buffalo. Even though they did give up a second-round pick for Hooker, the Bills believe it will be worth the cost and will help them reach the Super Bowl for the first time since the 1990s.
Simmons was dealt to the Chicago Bears, who are seen as Super Bowl front-runners with the emergence of Caleb Williams. Adding Simmons to a defense that is top 10 in both yards per game allowed and takeaways is only going to give that offense more opportunities.
There were three quarterback trades at the deadline and two involved the Minnesota Vikings. The first was trading J.J. McCarthy to the New York Giants. After drafting him in the first round in 2024, there were high hopes he would be able to be their next cornerstone at the position. However, the expectations did not match the play, and they dealt him to New York after Jaxson Dart went out for the year with a torn ACL.
The quarterback who will be starting on Sunday for Minnesota is Kirk Cousins, who was their quarterback before leaving after the 2023 season. He had the best seasons of his career in his first stint, passing for over 4000 yards and 25 touchdowns in four of his first five seasons before his sixth was cut short due to a torn Achilles. Rejoining this Vikings team, with arguably the best defense in the NFL, should make them legit threats for the Super Bowl.
The other quarterback trade was Jacoby Brissett going to the Baltimore Ravens to keep them afloat while Lamar Jackson comes back from injury. This has been a growing problem in Baltimore, as Jackson has missed time in each of the last two seasons. This year, however, Tyler Huntley also went down with an injury. Now they have to hope Brissett can put them in a position to continue playing football into January, when Jackson is scheduled to be healthy.
The only thing we can do now is see which trades end up being worth it for both sides. We saw last year how the Colts tried going all in, trading two first-round picks for Sauce Gardner, only to go winless after trading him and are now completely rebuilding. On the other end of the spectrum, we saw the Seahawks trade for Rashid Shaheed, and he helped contribute to them winning the Super Bowl last year.
