If you’ve spent any time on the internet in the past few years, you have probably stumbled upon this corner of the internet that is actively giving you advice on how to get off of the internet.

While I agree with the message, it’s the packaging that I, and many scientists, have a problem with.

Many of these creators place a heavy emphasis on mental and physical health from behind the screen, while benefiting from people interacting with their content online. The irony has always intrigued me.

The dopamine detox trend seemed to peak during the same time the “Clean Girl” fashion was taking over the internet around 2022-23. During this period, the goal was to be just online enough to send others the message you weren’t online at all.

Linen sheets, fresh flowers and a gratitude journal were the armor of these individuals. This was the opposite of the maximalist trends of the years 2016-20. It felt simple, graceful and, most of all, clean.

I realize how ridiculous that might sound to generations that do not have the same relationship with the internet that mine does. The online culture of this time was fixated on health and wellness. Yoga, matcha and journaling were the stars of many “day in my life” videos.

While the emphasis on health was refreshing, as always, it went deeper than just what viewers saw on the surface. Soon a new buzzword dropped and influencers clamored to use, and consequently abuse, its scientific nature.

Dopamine. The happy chemical. The reward chemical. The feel-good hormone.

Donning many names, dopamine became a topic no health influencer could stay away from. Armed with facemasks and overnight hair curlers, these creators started naming ways people could “reset” their dopamine levels – a problem most viewers didn’t even know they had.

So where did this fixation with dopamine come from? The hormone was discovered almost 70 years ago, why are we being told we need to get it under control now?

Artificial intelligence has given us an opportunity to rely on quick and easy information. In other words, we are surrounded by chances to experience a dopamine spike many times every day.

Dopamine hits can come from an assortment of different activities. Scrolling on social media, getting your favorite coffee, seeing that your crush texted you back or opening a gift are some common examples.

However, like all good things, too much can be harmful. Studies have shown that high levels of dopamine for extended periods of time can lead people to be more anxious, restless, irritable and even unable to sleep. You may experience this feeling after scrolling through TikTok for a little longer than you meant to.

Your brain is trying to regulate all the information it has just taken in while also dealing with a great influx of dopamine, which results in the stagnant feeling many have described.

So what is the solution? Cut it all out, obviously. Stop scrolling and only make coffee at home. Spend every morning without music and see where the boredom leads you. Set your phone to greyscale so the colorful icons on social media apps don’t lure you in.

This is what some videos on the internet would have you believe, but science says that is not the best reaction.

Each of these “solutions” has value that can lead to benefits, but the methodology behind them is questionable. I believe this reasoning stems from the current diet culture in which certain food groups are seen as “bad” and, in turn, should be completely excluded from one’s nourishment.

However, while it is possible for one to completely cut out carbs, there is no way to eliminate a chemical in the human brain. Furthermore, presenting this regime as a “detox” implies that dopamine is a toxin, which it isn’t. Any stimulus can become toxic in abundance, but that does not mean it is inherently harmful.

Let’s take a look at the science. It turns out that dopamine does not necessarily encode rewards, but reward prediction errors. This was discovered when researchers charted the brain activity of monkeys when they received treats.

Researchers rang a bell and awarded the animals with a treat. Eventually, the monkeys learned to associate the ring of the bell to receiving a treat. The scientists noticed that overtime, the dopamine in their brains spiked when they heard the bell, not when they received the treat itself.

There were three different outcomes: Dopamine could spike further, dopamine could stay at the same level or dopamine could drop further. This sheds light on human brain activity. This is why activities such as scrolling and buying your favorite treat can sometimes leave you feeling unsatisfied, even if you got exactly what you expected.

So, what should we do if not detox? A few answers can be found in some scientific articles such as “Reading for wellbeing: a realist review of evidence” from the National Library of Medicine, which supports the idea that reading books can be a very healthy way to regulate your brain’s dopamine spikes.

Spending time in nature can also encourage your brain to produce “happy” chemicals. You can also call a friend or try a new craft you’ve saved in a Pinterest board.

Dopamine is not a toxin, but an inseparable component of your brain’s chemistry. The answer to feeling better does not always lie in cutting something out, but changing your approach.